Skip to content

Pizza Quesadillas (Pizzadillas)

Pizza Quesadillas are a guaranteed family favorite meal. Grown-ups and kids have a blast with combining cheesy pizzas and crispy quesadillas into one. It’s the best of both worlds. Here’s how to throw your own pizzadilla party.

pizza quesadila with cheese and pepperoni

Crispy Pizza Quesadillas: favorite party food

What do you do when you go to make quesadillas, but realize you don’t have cheddar cheese, Monterey jack cheese, or any cheese that’s even a little bit normal for quesadillas (or you just want something different from the usual quesadillas?) 

Grab some mozzarella. And pepperoni…and some fixings for making pizza, because you can come away with quite possibly the best edible mashup ever. 

When I first thought of this genius combination of pizza + quesadilla, I thought I was a culinary rock star for inventing pizza quesadillas. I later realized I was, in fact, not the first creator of the pizzadilla. Nonetheless, I’ll still gladly accept compliments when serving these up for game day, casual gatherings, or Friday night with the family.

I mean, nobody gets upset over the stunning combination of all your favorite pizza toppings held together by crispy tortillas. 


pizza quesadilla with mushrooms, pepperoni, and bell peppers

Build Your Own Pizza Quesadilla Party

Lay out all the favorite fixings, several types of tortillas, and have a couple of nonstick pans ready to go. 

Then let ’em at it. Everyone builds their pizzadilla just the way they like:

  • Cheese: shredded mozzarella and plenty of it
  • Pepperoni: mini ones, thin cuts, turkey pepperoni, whatever kind you like
  • Thinly sliced mushrooms
  • Thinly sliced bell peppers
  • Thinly sliced tomatoes
  • Sliced olives
  • Sliced red onions
  • Pizza sauce (or pasta sauce) 
  • Alfredo sauce or white sauce
  • Cooked, chopped chicken 

Anything goes; even baby spinach leaves for white sauce pizzas, if you like. The beauty of build-your-own pizza parties is that there’s something for everyone. 

Because it’s a pizza-quesadilla, real guacamole is absolutely encouraged. 

pizza quesadilla build your own

Flour or Corn Tortillas

Both flour and corn tortillas work equally well; it’s completely dependent on what you and your eaters prefer. It’s recommended to have a few options available. 

Corn tortillas will likely fry up a bit thicker and heartier, though they’re often smaller in size than flour tortillas. Flour tortillas tend to fry up thinner and crispy. Either way, you can’t go wrong. 

Feel free to use larger fajita sized tortillas, or smaller taco sized ones. 

pizza quesadilla on plate

Pizza quesadilla Party Tips:

  • Do remind all the pizzadilla builders to leave a margin at the edges; otherwise, some of  the good stuff will seep out onto the pan instead of onto their plates.
  • Have all the fixings available to use in separate containers, preferably containers with lids. That way, when the party is over, you can easily pack leftovers away. 
  • It’s best to have at least 2 pans going on the stovetop; a cooking buddy is ideal.
  • Nonstick pans make for easy cooking and cleanup in this scenario.
  • Be sure oil is sizzling hot prior to putting down each quesadilla; this ensures each one cooks up crisp and browned, without being too greasy.
  • Have plenty of finger foods and snacks on the side: Gluten Free Ranch Snack Mix and 7-Layer Mexican Dip are absolute favorites. 

pizza quesadilla layered on plate

Other Party Foods to Make and Eat:

Print
pizza quesadilla

Pizza Quesadillas (Pizzadillas)

Pizza Quesadillas are a guaranteed family favorite meal. Grown-ups and kids have a blast with combining cheesy pizzas and crispy quesadillas into one. It’s the best of both worlds. Here’s how to throw your own pizzadilla party.

  • Prep Time: 10 mins
  • Cook Time: 5 mins
  • Total Time: 15 mins

Yield: Varies

Ingredients

  • Flour and/or corn tortillas
  • Marinara or pizza sauce
  • Mozzarella cheese, shredded
  • Pepperoni (I used HORMEL® Pepperoni)
  • Choice of Toppings: mushrooms, olives, sausage, peppers, tomatoes, etc.
  • Olive oil for pan

Instructions

  1. Place your ingredients in individual dishes. Let everyone build their own pizza quesadilla the way they like it (tip: leave a margin around edges so that sauce doesn’t leak when cooking.)
  2. On medium-high heat, heat enough oil in a large frying pan to coat the bottom surface. Once oil is hot/shimmering, place quesadilla in pan. Cook just until bottom is nicely browned; gently flip with a large spatula and repeat with other side. Slice as desired and serve immediately.

Notes

This is more of a how-to recipe, rather than a set recipe with specific amounts. Your amounts and choice of ingredients will depend on how many people there are and the toppings everyone likes.

  • Category: Pizza, quesadilla, main
  • Method: stovetop
  • Cuisine: Mexican American

Keywords: Pizza quesadilla, pizzadilla, build your own pizza, pizza party

Did you make this?

Leave a comment below and tag @chewoutloud on Instagram

 

Get our free email series: 5 Easy Recipes in 30 Minutes or Less

Plus our newest recipes each week