The Best soft chocolate chip cookies
It’s not even winter yet, but we’ve hit subzero temps already in this land. I’ve no qualms with staying in, turning up the kitchen heat, and baking madly away.
I’ve been up to my forehead in cookies galore. Even as I write, there are several batches of different holiday cookie dough sitting in my fridge, waiting for their turn in the oven. I do have an event to bring them to (wink.)
I realized a couple weeks ago: I’ve absentmindedly neglected to write up these superbly soft, chewy, and chocolatey chocolate chip cookies. Even though I bake them on a very regular basis.
These chewy soft chocolate chip cookies are my all-time favorite soft-batch style cookies that never fail when we want a sure thing that never misses the mark. These are soft, toothsome, winning cookies that stay soft – but not cakey – for a long time, without drying out.
It’s like your favorite pair of jeans… so loved, so well-worn, and nothing else fits the same. That’s what these chocolate chip cookies are like.
Never cakey, never dry
These chocolate chip cookies are … well, chewy ‘n soft. They stay soft without being cakey, and they don’t dry out or become stale. Fact is, they have never been put to the test longer than 2 days on our kitchen counter. But I just know they would stay soft several days longer if people would leave them alone.
These are reminiscent of those soft-batch chocolate chip cookies that were crazy popular in the 80’s, except this homemade version is undeniably more flavorful and fresh tasting. If you liked soft batch cookies, you’ll be blown away by these.
The secret’s in the pudding
The reason these chocolate chip cookies stay decadently soft is because they’re essentially pudding cookies. Adding powder vanilla pudding in the dough keeps these cookies luscious and soft, without being cakey or dry at all. The pudding also packs an extra boost of vanilla flavor to the cookies.
Gift them, share them, freeze them
I have a habit of making my cookies on the smaller side…I make them the way I want to eat ’em. If they are smaller, I can absolutely eat as many as I want. Because the truth? It is impossible to eat just one of these soft chocolate chip cookies. Impossible.
Gift giving, party hosting, or anytime sharing… these cookies magically appear and disappear in an instant. However, if you were to make a mountain of these soft chocolate chip cookies, they keep exceptionally well at room temperature and are a prime candidate for shipping to your favorite people on their birthdays or during the holidays.
I try to provide enough for the adults to grab their share before the rush of kiddos come charging in. Once The Littles get to the dessert table, these soft chocolate chip cookies are goners in about 2 minutes.
Bonus: both the dough and baked cookies freeze well in airtight containers. Freeze dough in one big ball or form pre-shaped rounds to freeze for easy baking anytime.