Instant Pot Baby Potatoes Recipe

Name: Instant Pot Baby Potatoes Recipe
Prep time: 5 min
Cook time: 5 min
Total time: 10 min
Yield: 4
Cuisine: American
Ingredients: 2 TB butter; 1 TB olive oil; 2 lbs baby potatoes, about 1.5 inches each, patted dry; 2 tsp dry Italian seasoning*; 1 tsp onion powder; 1 tsp garlic powder; 1 tsp paprika; 1 1/4 tsp kosher salt; 1/4 tsp freshly ground black pepper; 1/2 cup regular chicken (or veg) stock

This Instant Pot Baby Potatoes Recipe results in a supremely flavorful, tender potato dish. You’ll have saucy, garlicky, potatoes with just 5 minutes of cook time.

Once upon a time, there lived three boys who didn’t devour potatoes. That is, unless it was in the form of fries or taters. Otherwise, all baked potatoes, roasted potatoes, boiled and broiled potatoes…all such spuds were denied Devour Status.

One serendipitous day, their silly mama decided to make Instant Pot Baby Potatoes mostly because she impulsively threw a bag of baby potatoes into her cart while shopping on an empty stomach.

That mama fully expected that she [and the Hubby] would get to enjoy some garlicky roasted potatoes all for themselves. Who would’ve thought — all the boys shocked everyone with their sudden conversion into potato eaters.

I don’t know if the unforeseen rise of potatoes into Devour Status is due to young peoples’ ever changing taste buds, or due to the deliciousness of these Instant Pot baby potatoes, but who cares. All I know is I’ve made this potato recipe 3x this past week.

Grab some baby potatoes, toss them into your Instant Pot, and see what you think…

What Ingredients will I need for Instant Pot Baby Potatoes?

2 lbs Baby Potatoes: You’ll want fresh baby potatoes, about 1.5 inches each. That makes for a super fast spin in the Instant Pot, with even tenderness throughout each potato.
Dry Seasonings: We use Italian seasoning, onion powder, garlic powder, and paprika in the mix. A generous sprinkling of kosher salt and pepper are needed, as potatoes love to soak up the seasonings.
Olive Oil and Butter: The butter provides delicious flavor, while a bit of olive oil replaces some of the butter for a lighter dish.
Chicken Broth: A bit of broth provides just enough liquid to cook the potatoes to tender perfection, without the potatoes drying out.

What are some tips for the best instant pot potatoes?

Be sure to pat dry the potatoes in order to remove excess moisture
Mix the dry seasonings together in a bowl, prior to adding to the potatoes. It makes things way easier to pre-combine the seasonings
Be sure your oil/butter mixture is hot from Sauté mode button on Instant Pot, so potatoes can be quickly sautéed once they’re added to the pot. You can do this in 2 batches, if your pot is smaller or too full.
Close, lock, and seal lid and pressure cook on high for 5 minutes. After testing and re-testing, we found 5 minutes to be the perfect cook time.
Once your Instant Pot beeps, do a Quick Release (manually)… carefully vent the vale fully, open lid, and enjoy the deliciousness.

Why all the rage over Instant Pot Baby Potatoes?

They require only 5 minutes of cook time in the Instant Pot. Five and dine. (Hold the applause.)
You get to use Quick Release method of venting, which means your Instant Pot potatoes will be done even faster
The combination of herbs, olive oil, and butter creates a supremely flavorful potato dish
These Instant Pot potatoes are simple and delicious, with a garlicky sauce that automatically occurs during cooking.
Now you can clap.

What is the texture of these Instant Pot potatoes?

After many batches of potatoes trialed in the Instant Pot, we discovered that pressure cooking is better at braising than at roasting. In fact, it does a spectacular job at braising these baby potatoes.
Because the Instant Pot requires a bit of liquid during cook time, it produces extremely tender, flavorful potatoes with a delicious, naturally occurring sauce to spoon over your finished dish.
If you prefer your potatoes crispy on the outside, you can place them in a single layer under the broiler just until the exterior turns crisp. It won’t take long, so you’ll want to watch your broiler closely.

P.S. Because I’m becoming an Instant Pot freak, you’l find a mini roundup of IP faves below. Enjoy 🙂